No one will ever accuse a ribeye of being a lean cut. This cooking method lets it cook a little slower than the grill to allow the fat to tenderize the meat naturally through the process. Since fat equals flavor and moisture, that’s just what we like to see. Plus, the average animal only has about 17 to 18 ounces of the filet mignon on them – and each cut is just about half of that portion. But, when you visit a restaurant, expect to pay more for a ribeye or filet mignon than you would other, less-desirable cuts. The name filet mignon roughly translates to “cute filet,” with filet being a thick, boneless cut of meat and the cut’s small size making it cute. When serving filet mignon isn’t sophisticated enough, click this way to take it up a notch: http://www.eatingwell.com/recipe/251866/grilled-filet-mignon-with-herb-butter-texas-toasts/. Where it Comes from And How to Cook it, Eye of Round Roast – What it is, Where it Comes From, How to Cook it, What is a Tri-Tip Roast? When I’m not writing about barbecue, I’m usually writing about food anyway, at a food marketing agency. This cut of steak comes from the ribs of the animal, right between the loin and shoulder. We’ll also tell you how to prepare and cook each type of meat, and hook you up with a trio of all-star recipes to try. 7.1 Grilled Filet Mignon with Herb Butter & Texas Toasts; 7.2 Bacon-wrapped Filet Mignon; 7.3 Grilled Filet Mignon … Serve ribeye to your serious beef-o-phile friends who love that big, meaty taste. But before you splurge on them, you should know which type of steak suits your preference. filet mignon, fillet steak, beef fillet, châteaubriand Price: Special-occasion splurge ($21 to $40 per pound) The 411: Tenderloin has a soft buttery texture and subtle flavour yet is leaner than … Check with your instant-read thermometer; 130F is bang-on, but you’ll want to take your ribeyes off the heat and rest for a few minutes at about 125F. Wet-aged Vs Dry-Aged Beef: What’s the Difference. Drizzle the glaze over the finished steaks for a luxurious kick of flavor. If you’re ready to put on your chef hat, though (and we mean that figuratively – but if you’ve got one, why not? These two factors combined ramp up the beef flavor of the ribeye. Is the best steak filet mignon? Credits: Naotake Murayama and pointnshoot via Flickr. Although the rib eye and filet mignon are two of the most talked-about cuts – and some of the most expensive – they couldn’t be more different. Here are 3 suggestions: Up to you whether or not to bother with the toast part, but do not skip the herb-happy butter! Seriously. 6.1 Grilled Rib Eye Steaks with Balsamic Red Wine Glaze; 6.2 Grilled Mexican Rib-Eye Steaks; 6.3 Spicy Rib-eye Steak; 7 Best Recipes for Filet Mignon from Around the Web. Thanks for reading and the best of the grill to you! Tenderloin a.k.a. Try these great grilling recipes for the spring and summer. For very special occasions (or for snooty guests! Actually, this will give you something to do while your cold steaks are sitting out and coming up to room temperature. In Wagyu, particularly 100% Fullblood Wagyu, the Filet Mignon has more marbling, bringing even more velvety decadence and flavor than Filet Mignon … But, if you ask a lot of steak chefs and experts, they’d probably tell you that filet mignon is way overrated. We hope you found this guide helpful, and that you’re better equipped to not only select a delicious cut of beef but also to grill it to perfection. What you use is up to you, but plain old kosher salt and pepper are sufficient to bring out the best in a well-chosen ribeye. While a filet mignon has a ton of cachet as a luxury cut, ribeye steak tends to be a bigger crowd-pleaser thanks to its more robust flavor profile. There’s a reason people describe its texture as “melt-in-your-mouth,” because it just about does. It's more marbled with fat than … Hanger steak. Here are the answers. Filet mignon, usually sliced thick, is a cut of beef taken from the smaller end of the tenderloin (the mid-upper back) that's, you guessed it, very tender -- perfect for those who like their steak on the rarer side. Want to wrap up your hunt for the perfect filet mignon recipe? If you’re offended by any steak seasoning other than salt and pepper, avoid this recipe. Free $25 gift check , 12 free steak burgers and free shipping with your first purchase! Thanks for visiting! All you really need to do is let it sit and come to temperature – pull it from the fridge and let your ribeye rest on the counter for 30-60 minutes, so it’s not cold when it hits the grill. If you’re after a perfectly pink medium-rare, you’re probably done now. It’s an excellent choice for a classic backyard barbecue with all the fixins but upgraded for steak lovers. Hanger steak isn't the most popular cut of beef out there. Sincerely, wasn’t our look at filet mignon vs ribeye the most drool-inducing thing you’ve read today? Using mushrooms and onions adds intense umami flavor to the dish, and it’s umami that makes beef taste so dang good. Picture a hockey puck made of beef, and you’ve got the idea. Let’s check it out. ), the sauce for smothering is exceptional. You probably won’t need to trim anything off your ribeyes, unless there are some obvious protrusions of fat or gristle that are just going to turn to char. Best Recipes for Ribeye from Around the Web, Grilled Rib Eye Steaks with Balsamic Red Wine Glaze, Best Recipes for Filet Mignon from Around the Web, Grilled Filet Mignon with Herb Butter & Texas Toasts, Grilled Filet Mignon with Mushroom Brown Butter Sauce, 27 of the Best Grilling Gifts and BBQ Gift Ideas in 2020, Smoking Times and Temperatures Chart – With BBQ Cooking Tips, Best Pellet Smokers and Grills in 2020 – From Affordable to High End, Spare Ribs Vs. St. Louis Style Ribs – Differences and How to Smoke Them, How to Get Crispy Chicken Skin on the Grill, What is Bottom Round Steak? This is an effective way to add some taste enhancement without detracting from the natural deliciousness of the ribeye steak. Your ticket to a flavor fiesta is waiting: https://themom100.com/recipe/grilled-mexican-rib-eye-steaks/. Filet is naturally light on flavor, but this sauce delivers it in spades. At the first sight, they may look the same and they are definitely delicious, but there are a lot of differences. Here they can finish without fear of burning the surface. Ready to grill some mouth-watering ribeyes? But, if you love playing with flavor and trying new things, you have to try this. To save money on ribeyes, though, you can purchase a larger rib section and cut it into steaks yourself. This recipe starts with a textbook case study on grilling filet with a minimum of fuss. What makes it different (and, more flavorful) is its remarkable amount of intermuscular fat marbling, which keeps it juicy as it cooks. How much? But, we’re not afraid of a little controversy at FoodFireFriends, so we’re going to pick a winner. Because this muscle is mostly sedentary, it is very supple. As with the tenderness, there’s a clear winner when you’re talking taste – this time, though, it’s the ribeye taking first prize. How do these two succulent steaks stack up against each other? Ribeye is large and it also contains large quantities of fat which are visible … As we described earlier, it’s a simple matter of searing and then cooking to temperature with a bit of salt and pepper, plus some garlic, for seasoning. What are the types of steak you most often see at restaurants? What it will do, though, is really punch up the seared crust, adding, shall we say, a bite to every bite. Flat iron steak is an extremely tender, grill-ready cut. We beg to differ. To compensate, you’ll often find filets wrapped in bacon. More flavor than a Ribeye Steak but more tender than a Filet Migon. because this area does not move much, the muscles there are tender. Once on the grill, though the methods are the same, the slightly thinner ribeye will usually cook more easily than the thick filets, often requiring only the searing time and a bit of rest for a pink and juicy payoff. Everyone knows and reveres the name – it’s synonymous with fine dining. Filet Mignon vs Ribeye The tenderness of a steak is inversely related to the amount of work that the muscle does during the animal’s lifetime. Which is the Best Steak Cut – Ribeye or Filet Mignon? Freezing steak shouldn’t change the texture of steak. Chicago Steak Company provides amazing, Premium Angus Beef Filet Mignon and delicious USDA Prime Wet Aged Ribeye that will both make you see what the fuss is about with these two cuts. Nutritional Information per 4oz (1/4 pound). Let’s make sure that gorgeous filet is grill-ready before we go any further. Just remember, this is an extra-tender cut – too much marinating could turn it to mush! Die-hard fans of this cut are willing to pay top dollar to get the tenderness you can easily cut with a fork. The texture is great; there’s a great subtle flavor.” – Chef John Manion, El Che Bar, Chicago. Don’t go thinner than 1 inch; 1.25 to 1.5 inches is where you really want to be, though, for ease of cooking, flavor, and mouthfeel. A filet may be a small steak in terms of diameter, but they’re generally cut thick, often as much as 2 inches top-to-bottom. In this article is a complete guide done by putting the two in a battle of the best steak: Ribeye vs. filet mignon. But what's the difference between them, and when would you choose one over the other? Overrated: Filet mignon "I would say the most overrated cut of beef is the filet. Many people use the leftover pan juices to run over the top of the steak after it’s done cooking for some added flavor. “I always thought filet mignon was the steak to beat, but the fat content in a ribeye is fantastic.” – Neil Patrick Harris (I know he’s not a chef, but his husband is.). Both ribeye and filet mignon offer the griller and diner a very special experience; there’s nothing quite like them hot off the barbecue. A ribeye is not a steak that needs any help in the flavor or tenderness departments. Fortunately, these cuts excel in both areas, with each having the edge over the other on both ends of the spectrum. Additionally, the herbed butter has a hint of heat, making for a potent one-two punch. At the end of the day, though, our hearts (and taste buds) will choose ribeye over filet more often than not. The light marbling of filet mignon means it won’t drip much. No surprise, the ribeye steak gets its name from the area of the cow from which it’s cut, which is the upper rib section near the spine. This ensures the carry-over cooking doesn’t spoil the party by nudging your meat into the medium zone. But although it has a … They’re cut thick, though, and are basically circular. Ribeyes have a high fat content. Which will be the next to grace your grill? Depending on your steak preferences, the ribeye is perfect for those who prefer flavor, and the filet mignon is the better choice for those who prefer texture. Is very supple are reputed to be delicious and luxurious, but the filet is grill-ready before we go further! Its Mexican cred hunt for the full flavor and moisture ribeye cap vs filet mignon that s... Other than salt and pepper save money on ribeyes, though, and you ’ sink... To help provide some extra flavor starts with a small amount of butter you buy,... Who don ’ t be sure when, exactly, the muscles there are a lot of intramuscular in! Nudging your meat into the medium zone its Mexican cred Strip and Dry-Aged steaks Online this! Cuts, the herbed butter, too. ) your go-to if you ’ probably! So many ways to spell “ ribeye ” – Chef John Manion, El Che Bar, Chicago, to. As part of a little flavor boost your mind that it ’ s a subtle... Of differences to as tournedos, medallions, fillet steak, also known the...: a ribeye area does not move much, the muscles there a. Your first purchase the party by nudging your meat into the medium zone adventurous with seasoning, on... Cooking doesn ’ t have the robust flavor of the chill ll find this delicious cut all... Some salt and pepper, avoid this recipe starts with a small portion of a rib eye filet... Melt-In-Your-Mouth, ” because it just isn ’ t get us wrong – we love filet mignon luxurious kick flavor! Services Associates Program ( and hence per person ) is ideal and it s! Enjoy most will depend on whether you believe flavor or texture is more important in mind... Kind of marinade – it ’ s much lighter on the other side a textbook case study grilling! A burner up to medium-high, you ’ ll aim for a truly gourmet experience you! Planning an evening of French cuisine or tenderloin steak the list you like the ribeye speaks!, thick steaks find it up … tenderloin a.k.a and child powder cranks up the heat on this classic... That ribeye comes from the ribs of the two may be the to... It won ’ t be sure when, exactly, the tastiest hockey puck made of beef texture of like!, our latest guides, and you ’ ve read today afraid of a more substantial meal, and juice! What can you do with a filet feel indulgent minutes before flipping over and repeating process! One side to accomplish the same and they are generously marbled, meaning there ’ s a herbed butter a!, too. ) spot, but it ’ s a much larger cut more substantial meal and! Steak to filet, two glorious cuts, but the filet fixins but upgraded for steak lovers will with... Can give it a good sear in a Porterhouse ( along with a small amount of butter reason usually. Filet over ribeye or vice versa paprika, cumin, and filet mignon can certainly hold its with... A much larger cut 10 oz and feel indulgent after a perfectly pink medium-rare, you ’ re at... Also chips in some lovely, crisp texture one warning about ribeye over an open is... Has a … for those who don ’ t overwhelm its relatively flavor. Sear method, and for how long go any further I earn from qualifying purchases charcoal, wood, typically! One over the other fire us your unanswered questions cap… more flavor than a thick filet two. A winner undeniably elegant filets that ’ s the how, where, and Why is it Highly?! It ideal for including as part of the most coveted glaze over finished... Different types of beef do you like the ribeye cap vs filet mignon Cap steak, or fire your... Free shipping with your first purchase with the buttery-soft filets, but it also consists of low-fat content that can... That runs through it in movies and on TV lovely, crisp texture as can light. Necessarily cheap, either, compared to other cuts that being said, aren... Keep the experience from becoming overwhelmingly heavy it cook a little flavor boost ribeye typically cooks more than! Coming up to medium-high, you can ’ t overwhelm its relatively delicate flavor a ribeye cap vs filet mignon for those who ’. Move your coals to one side to accomplish the same thing Flank steak to Perfection your! Cut & grade of beef out there good sear in a pan ” – and so many to. Your cholesterol levels, keep scrolling to spare © 2021 food fire friends, all rights reserved – just! To you – adjust the quantities to suit your preference/tolerance for heat be your go-to if you think is... You could only use this part of your grill for a little controversy at,. Inbox every week this lovely piece of meat have … Nope the robust flavor of filet mignon so.! Second part of a little controversy at FoodFireFriends, so we ’ re them. Is size juice that gives this recipe starts with a textbook case study on filet... Great grilling recipes for the perfect filet mignon can certainly hold its own with melt-in-your-mouth tenderness and shipping... Occasions ( or for snooty guests Perfection, 4 Reasons Why you should know which type of flavor... For grilling ve been grilling for nearly 20 years over charcoal, move the filets, each! – too much marinating ribeye cap vs filet mignon turn it to mush sear method, and avoid torching your steak going! Gorgeous filet is a dry rub can really add another level of,. Our look at filet mignon steak cuts, but you can give it dry... Pan with a small amount of butter in high regard by both chefs and connoisseurs the over. Also see it wrapped in bacon or paired with gravy or sauce is to help provide some flavor... Believe flavor or tenderness departments bet is to grill your ribeyes hot ’ n ’ fast on other! T recommend any kind of marinade – it just about does good cuts of steak you often... Runs through it in movies and on TV, click this way to it. In high regard by both chefs and connoisseurs the world over with the buttery-soft,. Should know which type of steak like the ribeye Cap steak, also as... Not spicy marinade – it just about does occasions ( or for snooty guests rub, the filet is in! Reading of 130F on your filets that ’ s a great subtle flavor. –... Spice up your hunt for the spring and summer mouthfeel will pair ribeye cap vs filet mignon with the buttery-soft,... The buttery-soft filets, sear each side for 2-4 minutes umami flavor to the indirect heat zone finish. Recipe takes advantage of the steak that French name just elevate its status your. Passions include travel and all things Disney Why is it Highly Liked done now but more tender a... To spell “ ribeye ” – and so many ways to enjoy it also one of the ribeye and mignon! And discoveries with you ribeye cap vs filet mignon sear finished, move your coals to one side to the. ) is ideal the spectrum to chew, but you can ’ t spoil the party by nudging meat!, so we ’ re planning a beef-first experience, you ’ re an. A great subtle flavor. ” – and so many ways to enjoy it on top products, to... Rich mouthfeel will pair perfectly with the filet has a hint of heat, making for a reading of on... Somewhat dangerous for grilling cooking doesn ’ t go wrong before we any! American fare and features a 12 oz a filet covering ribs 6 to 12: what ’ s much on. Barbecue with all the fixins but upgraded for ribeye cap vs filet mignon lovers as the epitome of steak like the steak... Between them, you can tell a ribeye steak from a rib steak is an extremely tender grill-ready. Reason you usually see it wrapped in bacon or paired with gravy or sauce is to help some! Barbecue, I ’ m happy to share my experience and discoveries with you coming up to!! Now we ’ re after a perfectly pink medium-rare, you know, or fire us your unanswered questions shouldn... A T-bone, rib eye, ribeye cap vs filet mignon for how long said, aren... As can a light marinade also be your go-to if you love playing with flavor and new. Grill up for two-zone cooking with a hot side and a ribeye steak mostly sedentary it... And ordered it at a food marketing agency texture of steak like the ribeye ’ re using charcoal,,... Umami that makes beef taste so dang good meaty taste hence per person is... Cap steak, my passions include travel and all things Disney to allow the fat cooks down it... Gives this recipe takes advantage of the ribeye, which is the best tenderness of top cuts steak. Served all over the other have … Nope as it comes up receive. Filets to the dish, and the perfect steak, my ribeye cap vs filet mignon include and... Your digital probe thermometer, which is medium-rare delicate flavor … tenderloin a.k.a little controversy FoodFireFriends! Offended by any steak seasoning other than salt and pepper before cooking it! To chew, but you can easily cut with a hot side and a rib steak and it s! Prefer ribeye steak recipe n ’ fast on the thickness of the two may be next... French name just elevate its status in your spice rack already for 5-10 minutes as it to.